Local Government

TfL review finds floating bus stops pose ‘very low risk’

Transport for London says cyclist-pedestrian interactions are rare, but disability groups say injury data do not capture accessibility concerns.

Transport for London (TfL) has described the risk to pedestrians at floating bus stops as “very low”, prompting criticism from disability campaigners who say the layouts remain inaccessible and unsafe.

A floating bus stop, also known as a bus stop bypass, places a cycle lane between the pavement and the passenger waiting area. People boarding or leaving a bus must cross the cycle lane.

TfL reports limited recorded incidents

In one of three reports released by TfL, the organisation said it was “rare” for pedestrians and cyclists to interact at floating bus stops. Its analysis recorded five pedestrian casualties involving cyclists and one involving an e-scooter during the three-year period examined.

The report compared data from March to August 2018, before bus stop bypasses had been introduced, with data from March to August 2023, after their implementation. TfL also recorded 11,400 pedestrians injured by motorists over the same period, according to the report.

TfL acknowledged that floating bus stops might discourage some older and disabled people from using public transport, but said the proportion identified in its research was not statistically significant.

Campaigners challenge findings

Sarah Gayton of the National Federation of the Blind said bus stop bypasses were “absolutely abhorrent” and “not fit for purpose for all people”. She argued that official casualty figures understated the problem because incidents were often not reported.

“What we have is people not telling the police or reporting if they’ve been hurt, because they don’t know who’s at fault,” Gayton said. She has filmed several collisions, including five at the same floating bus stop near St Thomas’ Hospital in 2024. Those incidents fall outside the period covered by TfL’s analysis.

Erik Matthies, the Royal National Institute of Blind People’s policy lead for travel and transport, said RNIB research indicated that 40% of blind and partially sighted people avoided floating bus stops altogether.

“Low injury reports don’t tell the whole story – there is no safe and accessible way for people like me to cross the cycle lane to and from a bus stop, and today’s review from TfL does not address that,” he said.

More than 290 organisations representing blind, deaf, disabled, partially sighted and older people have previously written to the prime minister calling for floating bus stops to be removed from road infrastructure.

The Government paused the rollout of shared-use bus borders last year. That layout places the cycle lane across the front of the bus stop, but the pause did not prevent the future construction of bus stop bypasses.