Energy

PAC calls Sizewell C financing a ‘terrible deal’ for taxpayers

MPs warn consumers could face higher bills and taxpayers up to £54.4bn of exposure under the project’s regulated asset base model.

The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has described the financing structure for Sizewell C as a “terrible deal for the UK taxpayer”, warning that consumers and the public carry most of the project’s financial risk while private investors receive protected returns.

In a report published on 28 October, the committee said the 3.2GW nuclear power station on the Suffolk coast is expected to cost £38bn but could expose the public to up to £54.4bn through the government support package.

Consumers face risk of higher bills

The project is being delivered using a regulated asset base (RAB) model. The PAC said the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) had chosen a “novel delivery model” in which the government had relinquished majority control despite the public providing most of the financing and bearing most of the risk.

MPs said consumers could pay through higher energy bills if costs increase, while private investors face limited additional exposure to their capital. If construction costs reach the top of the department’s estimated range, £47.7bn, the committee said consumers could pay an additional £9.8bn during construction and a further £12bn over the plant’s 60-year operating life. Private investors would need to contribute only an additional £30m, it said.

The PAC also raised concerns over the public’s responsibility for other risks, including any final shortfall in funding for decommissioning. It said the exposure made it difficult to justify annual investor returns of more than 10% and questioned whether the incentives were strong enough to promote efficient delivery.

Concerns over delivery record and transparency

DESNZ and Sizewell C’s proponents have argued that repeating the design used at Hinkley Point C in Somerset will reduce risk. However, the PAC said no comparable nuclear power station anywhere in the world had been delivered on time and on budget, while projects using the same reactor design had experienced delays of up to 14 years and substantial cost overruns.

The committee also criticised plans to report publicly on cost overruns only once a year. It said annual reporting was “totally inadequate” for a project carrying this level of risk and called for Parliament and the public to receive the same six-monthly update, independently verified by a technical adviser, as shareholders.

PAC chair Geoffrey Clifton-Brown MP said the level of risk borne by taxpayers and consumers was “extraordinary”. He said the government needed to focus not only on delivering the power station but also on creating a commercially derisked nuclear sector.

Project backers defend the model

Sizewell C chief executive Nigel Cann said the project was “the right investment for Britain”, arguing that it would strengthen energy independence, support lower bills and provide reliable low-carbon electricity.

Cann said the replica design meant the project was better prepared than any other project in modern nuclear history, building on an established design, workforce and supply chain to improve productivity and reduce risk.

A DESNZ spokesperson said the PAC report ignored the incentives for investors to complete construction as cheaply and quickly as possible. The department said new nuclear was needed to move the UK away from expensive fossil fuels and towards clean, homegrown energy.

Nuclear Industry Association chief executive Tom Greatrex also defended the RAB model, saying it reduced costs for consumers by attracting private investment. He argued that repeating the same design was the most cost-effective way to provide additional baseload power.

Campaign groups Stop Sizewell C and Together Against Sizewell C welcomed the report and called for the project to be cancelled, arguing that public money should instead support renewables, energy storage and efficiency measures.