Highways

North Somerset considers re-tendering £33.4m A38 road scheme

The council says construction costs for Octavius’s Stage 2 proposal have exceeded approved funding, with a new procurement expected to add six months to the programme.

North Somerset Council is being asked to approve a new procurement process for the construction phase of its A38 Major Road Network scheme after forecast costs rose substantially above the project’s approved funding position.

Mike Bell, the council’s cabinet member for strategic partnerships, finance and corporate services, is due to present the recommendation to councillors on 10 November.

Cost forecast rises to £33.4m

Octavius was appointed last year as design-and-build contractor for the scheme, which covers nine locations along the A38 between Barrow Street, south-west of Bristol, and Junction 22 of the M5 near Edithmead.

According to a report prepared for the council meeting, Octavius has completed significant detailed design work and supported preparation of the project’s full business case under its Stage 1 contract. However, estimates for the Stage 2 construction contract, covering Packages A and B, are above the fixed funding allocation and available local contributions.

The council now estimates that Stage 2 will cost £33.4m, including contingency. The original procurement exercise indicated that the construction phase would need to be delivered within an indicative funding envelope of £18m.

The report said cost increases had been driven by design development, refined risk allowances, general construction inflation and supply-chain conditions, alongside higher costs for utility diversions and traffic management.

However, it added that independent benchmarking by consultants Rider Levett Bucknall had identified a “materially lower benchmark estimate than the current contractor proposal”. The council said the identified factors did not fully explain the difference between Octavius’s proposal and wider market expectations.

Fixed-price tender proposed

The council’s preferred approach is to end discussions on the current Stage 2 proposal and hold a new competitive procurement exercise. The proposed replacement contract would use the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract Option A, requiring contractors to submit a fixed-price tender rather than a target-cost proposal.

The report said the approach should provide a better balance between affordability, cost certainty, risk allocation and deliverability. It also said the original framework route used to appoint Octavius might not be used to find the replacement contractor, with available procurement routes and framework lots requiring further consideration.

Re-procurement is expected to add around six months to the programme. Council officers said the delay was proportionate to the opportunity to restore market competition, improve cost certainty and potentially avoid committing to a substantially higher construction cost.

The council said the re-tender was not expected to move completion beyond the Department for Transport’s spending deadline at the end of the 2029-30 financial year.

North Somerset Council announced the previous week that it had secured £26m in government funding for the project, which is intended to improve the A38 and connectivity between local communities.

Octavius and North Somerset Council have been contacted for comment.