Environment

CCC warns weaker ZEV mandate could put UK climate targets at risk

The Climate Change Committee says reducing zero-emission vehicle targets could increase oil imports, raise costs and make emissions reductions more difficult.

The UK is likely to miss its legal climate targets if the Government weakens the Zero-Emission Vehicle (ZEV) Mandate, the Climate Change Committee (CCC) has warned.

CCC chair Nigel Topping has written to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander setting out the independent adviser’s position on the Government’s review of the mandate, alongside new analysis of its economic and energy security implications.

Higher oil use and costs

The CCC said the Government’s impact assessment indicates that reducing the headline ZEV targets could increase UK fuel consumption by 15 million barrels of oil a year by 2030.

At current prices, the additional oil would cost more than £1bn a year and would need to be sourced from international markets, according to the committee.

The CCC also said switching to electric vehicles could help protect households from future energy price volatility. It estimates that a typical household could save about £800 a year by moving to an EV.

Electric vehicles are expected to deliver the largest share of emissions reductions in the Government’s Carbon Budget and Growth Delivery Plan through to 2037, the committee said. Weakening the mandate would therefore make the Sixth Carbon Budget, covering 2033 to 2037, more difficult and expensive to meet.

The policy also supports the separate carbon budgets of the Scottish and Welsh Governments and the Northern Ireland Executive. The CCC said any changes should consider the effect on those administrations’ ability to meet their targets.

Industry and local air quality concerns

UK100 said independent modelling for the Clean Air Fund suggests that cutting the 2030 target from 80% to 60% would increase toxic emissions by almost 9% and add £561m in health costs. It said the effects would be felt most heavily by communities located close to busy roads.

Christopher Hammond, chief executive of UK100, said councils were investing in public chargepoints and clean-air schemes and that weakening the mandate would leave families paying more for fuel while being exposed to poorer air quality.

ChargeUK said a reduction in the targets could put £1.7bn of charging investment at risk. Its chief executive, Shane Brennan, said charging companies were building infrastructure ahead of the demand trajectory set by the mandate.

New AutoMotive chief executive Ben Nelmes said electric cars accounted for 32% of the market in October, compared with a 25% manufacturer requirement for the year once flexibilities were included. He called for the Government to retain the targets and close the plug-in hybrid loophole.

The CCC’s intervention comes as the Government reviews the operation of the ZEV Mandate, which requires manufacturers to increase the proportion of new cars and vans sold that produce no tailpipe emissions.

CCC calls for policy certainty

Topping said weakening the mandate would undermine the UK’s competitiveness, increase exposure to volatile fossil fuel prices and remove certainty for businesses investing across the supply chain.

“The market has already evolved, and the UK should be accelerating to keep up, not putting the brakes on,” he said.

The CCC chair also said the UK ranked 22nd globally for EV sales, behind France and Germany, which are among its key competitors in car manufacturing.

ChargeUK urged ministers to focus instead on reducing the cost of public charging. It called for VAT equalisation, a renewable fuel credit scheme and changes to network charges overseen by Ofgem.

Polestar UK managing director Matt Galvin said the ZEV Mandate was driving investment and innovation, and warned that a major change would risk investor confidence, reduce consumer choice and potentially increase prices.