One in five construction contractors say the health and safety procedures set out in their organisations’ policies do not consistently reflect what happens on site, according to a survey commissioned by Veriforce Chas.
The research found that 22% of respondents had seen a frequent gap between written policy and site practice, despite 90% rating construction health and safety standards as good or excellent.
Enforcement and training concerns
Weak on-site enforcement was identified as the leading barrier to meeting safety requirements, cited by 26% of contractors. A further 25% pointed to insufficient training or competence, while 24% cited poor communication.
The survey also indicated inconsistency in near-miss reporting. While 39% of respondents said near misses were reported more often than five years ago, 31% said reporting had declined over the same period.
Evidence of competence was not routinely requested before work began. Some 45% said they were typically required to provide evidence of their competence, qualifications or training, compared with 57% who said they had to submit health and safety policies and procedures.
The survey was conducted by 3Gem among 500 contractors between 17 and 28 July.
Call for stronger reporting culture
Ari Fatah, technical standards manager at Chas, said under-reporting near misses could give organisations an inaccurate view of their safety performance.
“Where near misses go unreported, organisations can appear to have a positive safety record when the reality of onsite safety could be very different,” he said. “On busy construction sites with moving vehicles, heavy equipment and multiple professions, reporting a near-miss can feel like reporting a non-incident. But failing to report them can allow unsafe practices to continue – effectively putting everyone onsite at risk.”
Fatah added that clearer communication and stronger enforcement could help workers raise concerns and enable companies to introduce controls before incidents result in injury or more serious accidents.
“By encouraging a proactive safety culture, where there’s clear communication around health and safety and on-site enforcement, workers can feel confident raising near-miss and safety concerns,” he said. “This means we’re able to identify areas for improvement and put controls in place before they lead to injuries or serious accidents.”
Building Safety Act impact
Some 84% of respondents said the Building Safety Act 2022 and subsequent changes to building regulations had changed how their organisations demonstrate competence. The changes had increased the focus on evidence of skills, experience, qualifications and training.
Fatah said people carrying out or managing building work must have the appropriate skills and qualifications, while those appointing them must take reasonable steps to verify their competence.
“Failing to properly demonstrate and verify competence can create significant regulatory, operational and reputational risk,” he said. “Independent verification and industry recognised certifications, such as Safety Schemes in Procurement (SSIP) and Common Assessment Standard (Cas), give a consistent baseline for assessing contractor competence and help drive higher standard across the industry.”

