Rail

Government launches review of UK rail construction costs

A six-month review led by WSP’s Rachel Skinner will examine why UK rail projects are expensive to design and deliver.

The government has launched a review into the cost of delivering rail infrastructure projects in the UK, with recommendations expected within six months.

The review was first set out in the Northern Growth Strategy and was reaffirmed by Chancellor of the Exchequer John Healey in September. It will examine costs across the design and delivery of rail projects and propose changes for government and industry.

Scope of the review

Rachel Skinner, WSP’s managing director for transport and mobility, will lead the work. She will be able to make recommendations on any factors she considers relevant.

Evidence will be gathered through analysis, interviews and round-table discussions, supported by an expert panel. The review will consider how projects are initiated and specified, including decisions on capacity, speed and integration with the existing network.

It will also assess whether designs are sufficiently developed before contracts are agreed, how costs are benchmarked and whether decision-making remains clear throughout a project.

Other areas under consideration include procurement, the allocation of risk between government bodies, rail organisations and suppliers, and the impact of devolution to mayors.

Planning, delivery and investment

The review will examine the role of planning, environmental and safety requirements, including nationally significant infrastructure projects, Transport and Works Act orders and the use of recent reforms such as the Planning and Infrastructure Act.

It will also consider whether long-term investment plans and a steady pipeline of work could improve productivity and reduce costs.

Its terms of reference call for comparisons with rail schemes and other infrastructure projects in the UK and overseas. The work is intended to build on earlier reviews of project governance and infrastructure delivery, as well as the government’s 10 Year Infrastructure Strategy, which identified a need to reform institutions and delivery methods.

The Department for Transport’s Major Rail Projects Group policy and benefits director will act as the review’s client. A panel including officials from the department, HM Treasury, Network Rail and other government bodies will support the work and advise on implementing its recommendations.

A government statement said: “The review’s recommendations should be evidenced by drawing comparisons between, and learnings from, the delivery of rail projects in the UK, and other infrastructure projects both in the UK and in other major economies. This is to help identify recommendations likely to reduce the design and delivery costs of UK rail projects in future.

“The review’s recommendations should be ambitious, practical and forward looking, with a view to influencing the delivery of future rail infrastructure schemes.”