Transport for Wales has pushed back the full rollout of its £200m-plus South Wales Metro tram-train fleet to the end of 2027, five years later than originally promised.
Only 16 of the 36 three-carriage Class 398 Citylink units have passed the statutory testing required for operation on the UK rail network, according to data obtained by the BBC through a Freedom of Information request.
Six of the trains are currently being used for passenger testing on the valleys network. The remaining vehicles have been stored, including at TfW’s new depot near Cardiff, which has cost about £100m.
Software and testing delays
The tram-trains, built by Swiss manufacturer Stadler, were ordered in 2018 and the first unit arrived in Wales in March 2023. They are designed to operate both on conventional railway lines and urban streets, with batteries allowing them to run on sections without overhead wires.
TfW chief executive James Price said the trains had experienced software-related “teething issues” and “early reliability challenges”. He said the organisation wanted vehicles that worked “100% well, 100% of the time” before introducing them across the network.
“Everyone would want something to work first time, wouldn’t they? It’s frustrating but not unexpected,” Price said.
TfW said testing periods had varied from six weeks to two years. The operator also said delays to electrification, partly linked to the Covid pandemic and supply-chain disruption following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, had affected the programme.
Stadler said it was working closely with TfW to address minor issues. The manufacturer said testing and validation had progressed in phases, allowing software updates and other normal refinements to be implemented.
Four trains an hour target
The £2bn South Wales Metro programme is intended to transform services on the former valley railway network. TfW says the tram-trains are the final major element needed to deliver more frequent, turn-up-and-go services.
The operator plans to increase services from two to four trains an hour between Cardiff and Aberdare, Merthyr Tydfil and Treherbert by the end of 2027. New Class 756 trains have operated on those routes since 2024, while the smaller, purpose-built tram-trains have been delayed.
Once the Class 398 fleet is fully introduced, the Class 756 units are intended to move to the Bridgend-Rhymney route.
Price said TfW also needed to train several hundred members of staff and complete signalling work at Cardiff Queen Street station. He said he expected four trains an hour on the three routes “by the end of next year definitely”.
Rail engineer and broadcaster Gareth Dennis said the project combined several complex technologies, including tram operation, railway systems, battery power and discontinuous electrification.
“The challenge of having such complicated trains trying to do everything to reduce the cost of the infrastructure requires a lot of stuff to be working on the train,” he said.
TfW says avoiding full overhead electrification has saved about £400m and reduced the time needed for construction. The Welsh Government said the operator remained on target to complete the rollout by the end of 2027.

