Highways

A83 convoy plan could cost Argyll economy £500m, businesses warn

Campaigners say up to four years of convoy-controlled traffic during construction at the Rest and Be Thankful could cause major economic losses.

Businesses and campaigners have warned that proposed convoy controls during construction of a permanent landslide protection scheme on the A83 could cost the regional economy about £500m.

The estimate relates to plans to use the Old Military Road as a diversion while a debris flow shelter is built at the Rest and Be Thankful in Argyll and Bute. Construction of the permanent scheme is expected to take three to four years.

Alternative routes under review

Minutes from the A83 Taskforce record campaign group chairman John Gurr warning of direct losses of approximately £500m over four years if a two-way route is not maintained. He also cited potential indirect impacts, including business failures.

The £500m figure is a campaign estimate, rather than the cost of the road project or an independently assessed economic impact.

Options being considered include upgrading a forestry track for two-way traffic, widening the Old Military Road for two-way use, and combining the two routes into a one-way circuit. Campaigners support the forestry track option.

Transport Scotland has argued that improvements to the Old Military Road would provide a more resilient diversion more quickly and at relatively lower cost. The agency has also warned that changing the proposed interim arrangement could have significant implications for the programme and cost of the permanent scheme.

Permanent scheme cost

Scottish Government documents estimate the permanent solution at between £408m and £510m at late-2024 prices. The proposed debris flow shelter is intended to protect the A83 from landslides.

Minutes from September’s taskforce meeting record Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn acknowledging stakeholders’ concerns. He said he wanted to consider the additional assessment work fully before deciding how to proceed.