The High Court has refused to allow specialist lift manufacturer Serapid to enforce a £416,499 adjudication award against Octavius Infrastructure over cancelled works at Chalkwell station in Essex.
Mr Justice Moody dismissed Serapid’s application for summary judgment on 22 October 2026. The ruling does not finally decide whether a contract existed or whether Serapid is entitled to payment, but prevents the award being enforced through the summary judgment route for now.
Dispute over cancelled lifts
Serapid had spent about five months working on lifts for a Network Rail step-free access project involving a replacement footbridge at Chalkwell. Octavius told the manufacturer on 7 November 2025 that the lifts were no longer required and said it had “no contractual obligation” concerning their manufacture or installation.
The companies had previously worked together on a similar Network Rail scheme at Grays station. They signed an initial design subcontract for Chalkwell in August 2024, while negotiations over a separate subcontract for manufacturing and installing the lifts continued through 2025.
Serapid quoted £872,175 for the work in February 2025. The parties continued negotiating an NEC3 subcontract, with Serapid later submitting a revised quotation of £1.065m in October.
Octavius senior project manager Bradley Mansbridge told Serapid by email on 16 June that he believed the outstanding legal and commercial issues had been resolved and that a subcontract order would follow that week. However, Serapid had begun procurement on 3 June and continued manufacturing without a signed subcontract.
Adjudication award challenged
Serapid began adjudication proceedings, seeking £667,526 for what it described as the wrongful termination of a contract. Adjudicator Wayne Lord concluded that the parties had agreed substantive terms with “sufficient clarity” by around 6 June 2025 and that “a contract existed”. He awarded Serapid £416,499, excluding VAT, plus £29,250 in adjudicator’s fees.
Octavius paid the adjudicator’s fee but challenged his jurisdiction, arguing that the parties had never entered into a binding subcontract.
Mr Justice Moody said there was evidence that neither side considered itself legally bound, despite key terms appearing to have been substantially agreed by late June. The evidence included correspondence indicating that a formal subcontract was still expected, alongside ongoing negotiations over price and other commercial matters.
The judge also referred to Serapid’s internal execution strategy, which authorised manufacturing preparations “prior to being under contract”. He said the fact that Serapid had continued manufacturing for five months did not, on its own, establish that a contract had been agreed.
Serapid alternatively argued that the parties had reached a simpler oral agreement. The judge rejected that argument because it had not been pleaded or considered in the adjudication, and because there was insufficient clarity about how or when such an agreement had been made.

