The UK’s Historic Railways Estate (HRE) is set to move from National Highways and the Department for Transport (DfT) to Great British Railways (GBR), transport minister Peter Hendy has confirmed in the House of Lords.
The proposed transfer was discussed during consideration of an amendment tabled by Conservative peer Lord Young of Cookham. The amendment received support in the Lords, while Hendy said the government intended for the estate to become part of GBR’s responsibilities.
Concerns over risk-based management
The HRE comprises roughly 3,100 legacy bridges, tunnels and viaducts. Young said the assets had been managed primarily through a highway safety and liability perspective, which he argued had encouraged demolition or infilling rather than reuse.
“The estate currently rests with National Highways, and the briefing I have been given shows that they take a risk-averse approach towards its management,” he told peers.
Young said the DfT’s preference for transferring ownership to another statutory body had restricted opportunities for leasing structures to heritage railways, active travel schemes and cycle routes. He added that the approach had led to “perpetual decline” for some structures and the loss of potential social and economic benefits.
The House of Lords Transport Committee criticised National Highways’ stewardship in 2021, urging the organisation to treat the disused structures as public assets rather than financial risks.
Great Musgrave bridge cited as example
Young referred to the Great Musgrave bridge in Cumbria, where National Highways filled the 8.4m single-span masonry arch with around 1,000t of concrete between May and July 2021. The work cost £124,000.
Following local and engineering opposition, Eden Valley district council rejected a retrospective planning application for the infilling and ordered its removal. National Highways later revealed that removing the material cost £352,000. The process took 13 weeks and caused some damage to the structure, according to the supplied account.
No additional strengthening or weight restrictions were introduced after the infill was removed. The decision was criticised by campaigners, who said the infilling had also prevented potential links between two heritage railways and possible active travel use beneath the bridge.
“I have been given other examples of bridges in Hertfordshire and tunnels in Wales where this risk-averse approach of a body not set up to manage heritage railway structures has meant lost opportunities for imaginative reuse,” Young said.
Transfer mechanism included in legislation
Hendy said the legislation already contained a mechanism to enable the move, pointing to Clause 88, which provides a legal framework for transfer schemes. The clause was agreed in the House of Lords.
Lord Grayling said returning the estate “to the railway world” was overdue. He argued that its management should protect possible extensions to heritage and reopened railway lines, preserve corridors that could be needed if rail demand increases, and safeguard biodiversity.
“It would be an absolute travesty if the opportunity to achieve that growth were lost because of ill-advised planning decisions or land sales now,” Grayling said.
Hendy linked the proposed change to the wider role intended for GBR, including reconnecting communities and supporting underserved areas. He said the previous Restoring Your Railways programme had produced many centrally selected projects that were not funded or delivered.
“GBR will be best placed to consider future investments in the railway, ensuring that new investments in infrastructure support its general plan to fulfil its duties and make a better railway for everyone,” he said.

